Tuesday 8 September 2009

The Knife of Never Letting Go by Patrick Ness

Pages 479

Published by Walker Books in 2008

Challenges - 100+ books

First paragraph.

The first thing you find out when yer dog learns to talk is that dogs don't got nothing much to say. About anything.

'Need a poo, Todd.'

'Shut up, Manchee.'

'Poo,poo, Todd.'

Is it possible to love and hate a book at the same time. Well, it has to be, because this is how this book made me feel. I loved majority of it, yet there were parts that frustrated me and parts that I absolutely hated because of the effect they had on me.

The main character in this book is Todd, a young boy about to reach his thirteenth birthday. He lives in what can only be described as a dystopian style town. He lives in a town called Prentisstown, where there are no women left. In the town, everyone can hear everyone else's thoughts all the time. There is no chance of any privacy as everyone knows what your secrets are.

During a walk with his dog to collect apples, he stumbles across a spot of complete silence. An area where he can hear absolutely nothing. This shouldn't be and Todd becomes confused. Has his hometown lied to him. Todd's discovery leads him into danger and now he must run for his life.

This book is written in present tense, so you get a sense of urgency right from page one. I found this difficult to read for the first few pages, then after a while I forgot all about it and lost myself in the story. The way Todd talks can be quite difficult to follow, as he has suffered from a lack of a formal education. I struggle to read prose when the words are mispelt and have an urge to get my red marking pen out for corrections.

At the beginning of this post I told you I loved and hated it. I will start with the part I hated because I still get angry about it. There is a part in the book, that I wasn't expecting and I found it really upsetting. I am not going to tell you what it is, because that would spoil it for you and you may not be affected by it as I was. For me, there were real tears, to the point I had to put the book down and go and do something else. Then when I picked it up again, I was drawn back to the part that upset me, just to convince me that it did actually happen. I have even moaned in a previous post, that I wish someone had warned me. I still can't see why it had to happen and I am sure there were other ways the story could be written.

The part I found frustrating was the pace of the book. From the beginning, the book is intense and in parts I felt quite breathless by how fast everything was happening. It is the type of story where the characters are constantly in trouble and never get a chance to recover from the previous incident before something else lands on them. If I had been one of the characters, I would definitely have laid down and given up.

Ok, that is the horrible part and the frustrating part out of the way. Now for the good bits.

I loved the characters in the book. Manchee, the talking dog was my absolute favourite and I know anyone who has read the book will be looking at my childish humour with disdain. I found Manchee to be really entertaining, to the point I was actually quoting Manchee's words when my own dog needed the toilet.

The twists and turns in the plot of this story were mind blowing. There are so many unseen parts to the plot that crop up. The world Todd lives in constantly changes as you read the book. Everything you believe about Todd and his world in the beginning will lie in shattered pieces by the end and you will be looking at a whole new world.

This book has a lot of violence in it and I did flinch quite a bit, but the violence just made the story more real. Personally, I don't cope well when violent situations are described so vividly. There is a degree of feminism within the story and from what I have heard about Book Two this is taken a lot further.

On the whole, I think I loved it and would recommend to anyone who enjoyed The Hunger Games, only this one is lot more violent and will leave you with a mind full of questions.

I am definitely going to read the follow up The Ask and The Answer because I have to know what happens next. I can't possibly carry on with out knowing. At least with the second book I will be prepared for the violence.

Other reviews.

Things that mean a lot


The Zen Leaf


  1. Since I enjoyed the Hunger Games perhaps I should read this book then...hm

  2. I really loved The Hunger Games but I'm not quite sure about this one. I think it is really hard to read a story about children when it also contains lots of violence. In The Hunger Games we know there is violence but it is kind of toned down in a way that makes it readable to me.

  3. I haven't read The Hunger Games but this does sound intriguing... think I will definintely look out for it.

  4. The idea of the book sounds interesting. I haven’t read The Hunger Games, so I will have to check it out. Thanks for your honest review!

  5. I am still very on the fence about this one. I actually don't like the dog at all, the pace was way too fast, and the whole thing felt like a big car chase scene. Then again, it was intriguing, I certainly got sucked into the book, and I felt like I had to read the next book immediately. Of course, it took me several months before I was able to get ahold of an ARC, and though it's been almost 2 months since then, I haven't felt compelled to read it. I've started it, and plan on reading it very, very slowly. I think my problem with this book was that I read it way too fast. If I'd have force myself to slow down, I'd probably have liked it better.

    But that part that disturbed you, it actually didn't bother me at all because I couldn't connect with that particular character. I'm trying not to give away spoilers. :)

  6. Hmmm - sounds like it's worth a read. Good review! You did a good job of detailing your dislikes without giving out too much information!

  7. Ladies - if you have not read the Hunger Games, you really really must. It is fabulous and the violence is downplayed a lot and happens out of view.

    The violence in this book is very graphic and a little upsetting, so if you haven't got a strong stomach, then don't read it.

    Amanda, I could tell you didn't connect to the same character as I did. I will probably have to try and read the second one slower too.

  8. Okay, Vivienne, you got me hooked again (Loved The Hunger Games, and just got book two) and I will put this one on my wishlist!

  9. Oh man, you have no idea how badly I want to read your post!!! I'm not allowing myself to because I just started this book myself. But I'll be back to compare notes when I finish. :D

  10. Wow, this is definitely not a book that I would have picked up just from the cover. Even from the description I would probably have been turned off. But your review really makes me want to read this book just to find out what happens. Great review!

  11. Oh, I know what you mean about typos and misspellings in a book - they drive me crazy. I'm really curious about what happened in this book now.

  12. That's an interesting review, Viv! I love books that gives me this pleasure of loving and hating it at the same time. I think I'll give this a try.

  13. Ah, the oassionate reader loves & hates a book -- typos do drive me crazy but I often fly by them it is sometimes no big deal. Viv, sometimes.

  14. Warning: the second book is even darker! There was nothing that affected me quite as much as that one bit, but that was just because...well, I can't stay more without spoilers, but I know what you mean and I know you know what I mean :P

  15. I had to get this one, and am now just waiting for it to arrive. Still have Hunger Games 2 and World as we knew it to read first though.


Hiya, thanks for stopping by, it is always nice to hear what you have to say, so do leave a comment if you have time.